Heathers The Musical
Updated: Oct 26

Heathers The Musical opened last night to expectant applause and closed to a
standing ovation. This latest in the series of new modern musicals is based on Michael Lehmann’s 1989 black comedy and manages to retain all the danger, discomfort and thought-provoking and no shortage of gallows humour.
Heathers is set in a stereotypical High School (think more 13 Reasons Why rather than Grease) with the usual groups of jocks, nerds, cool kids and, of course, Heathers. Here, the Heathers, three rich and entitled seniors, control who is in, who is out and who deserves to be just left alone.
Veronica (Jenna Innes – Les Mis, Spoonful of Sherman) is a plain Jane who wants to be noticed more and so attempts to befriend the Heathers. Usually this would be met with an acerbic put-down, but Veronica has talent for forging handwriting and as such the Heathers see this (and Veronica’s not-so-subtly disguised beauty) as reason to bring her into the gang.
The Heathers; Chandler (Lizzie Emery), Duke (Elise Zavou) and McNamara (Billie Bowman) begin to force Veronica to turn her back on her friends and adopt their callous, snide and bitchy approach to their classmates. This doesn’t sit well with Veronica but the rewards of attention prove too big a draw to refuse so she does their bidding, albeit under duress.
Seeking someone she can confide in, Veronica falls for Jason ‘J.D.’ (Tom Dickerson) a new guy at school who she soon finds is more lone wolf than Lonely Soul, and he begins to lead her into revenge on the Heathers and all those who follow them.
There is no mistaking the darkness in this production; murder, poisoning, teen suicide, attempted date rape are some weighty topics but they are delivered in the guise of High School life and Director Andy Fickman hits the right level every time. The score is a bit samey, with most numbers following the stereotypical ‘start low and end with a belt’. With the majority of the roles being teenage girls or just-pubescent boys they are all in the same register which leaves you crying out for some deeper voices.
What really let the show down however, and this was echoed by many seated around us in the circle, is the sound system - it was badly balanced and mixed which made it nigh on impossible to hear many of the lyrics & wordplay over the garbled noise. This, sadly seems all too often nowadays – in part due to composers and lyricists writing numbers which sound great in rehearsals when everyone knows what is being sung (and are in very close proximity) but who then feel that to project to a full auditorium means just crank up the volume.
Fast-paced, word-heavy songs featuring multiple voices demand exceptional clarity. When the balance isn't right, the lyrics become lost in a wall of sound, particularly for audiences seated further from the stage. With sound checks generally conducted in an empty auditorium, it's possible that the experience in the circle differs considerably from that at the mixing desk. Sadly, several people seated around us appeared to be struggling to follow the lyrics, with some even adjusting their hearing aids in an attempt to improve matters.
Heathers The Musical played at Darlington Hippodrome in October 2023, with performances concluding on Saturday 7 October.
Revisited in 2026: We returned to Heathers The Musical at Darlington Hippodrome three years later and discovered a production that addressed many of our earlier reservations. Read our 2026 review



Comments