Heathers The Musical 2026
THIS Heathers deserves to be popular.
Heathers The Musical opened at Darlington Hippodrome to a huge and clearly expectant audience, and judging by the reaction around me, this was a theatre packed with fans who knew exactly what they had come to see.
From the opening bars to the final curtain, the audience lapped up the gallows humour, cheered the characters and celebrated the leading cast as though they were rock stars. On this evidence, Heathers has certainly found its audience – and, on this occasion, I found myself rather more readily joining them than I expected.
Based on Michael Lehmann’s 1989 black comedy, Heathers retains all the danger, discomfort, dark humour and thought-provoking themes of the original film, transporting us into the very particular world of Westerberg High School.
Think less Grease and more 13 Reasons Why, where the usual school hierarchy of jocks, nerds, outsiders and the impossibly popular reigns supreme. At the top of that particular food chain sit the three Heathers – rich, beautiful and utterly ruthless – who decide who is in, who is out and who is destined to become tomorrow’s gossip.
Veronica Sawyer (Gerardine Sacdalan) is desperate to escape her status as one of the school’s nobodies and finds her opportunity when her talent for forging handwriting earns her an invitation into the Heathers’ inner circle. Chandler (Liberty Stottor), Duke (Jessica Ibadin) and McNamara (Lou Henry) soon begin to reshape Veronica in their own image, encouraging her to abandon old friendships and embrace their cruel and callous approach to those beneath them.
It works, at least initially, until Veronica meets Jason ‘J.D.’ Dean (Louis Hearsey), the mysterious new boy who offers an altogether darker solution to the problems created by the Heathers.
And there is no shortage of darkness here. Murder, poisoning, suicide and sexual violence are all woven into a story which, on the surface, looks like a colourful romp through American high school life. It is a difficult balancing act, but Andy Fickman’s direction gets that balance absolutely right, allowing the humour to land without diminishing the darker themes.
Indeed, this is the best production of Heathers I have seen.
The performances are powerful, funny and, when required, genuinely disturbing. Sacdalan makes Veronica an engaging and increasingly complex central character, while Stottor, Ibadin and Henry embrace the outrageousness of the three Heathers with exactly the right combination of humour, arrogance and menace. Hearsey’s J.D. provides the necessary darker counterpoint, bringing a suitably unsettling edge to the relationship.
And perhaps most pleasingly, the clarity issues that have troubled me in previous productions have been largely overcome. The songs remain fast, word-heavy and deliberately energetic, but this time the lyrics and wordplay were there to be heard. That makes a considerable difference to a show where so much of the humour and storytelling is contained within the music.
There is also something rather prescient about Heathers. This is the original ‘cancel culture’ expose, long before the internet, social media and the modern obsession with ‘likes equal validation’. It lays bare the shallowness of popularity, the consequences of alienation and the damage caused when acceptance becomes more important than individuality. And beneath all the darkness and humour sits an uncomfortable reminder that genuine, unselfish kindness can sometimes be in frighteningly short supply.
Heathers may be more than three decades old, but much of what it has to say feels remarkably contemporary.
This is a hugely entertaining production, brilliantly performed and confidently directed, and one I am very happy to recommend. If you've seen Heathers before, this cast and production are more than worth another visit. If you've never experienced Westerberg High, there's no better excuse to put on your red scrunchie and find out what all the fuss is about.
Another great evening at Darlington Hippodrome – and this time, one that exceeded my expectations by some considerable distance.
Heathers the Musical is on at Darlington Hippodrome until Saturday 26th September, tickets from https://www.darlingtonhippodrome.co.uk/ or 01325 40540.
Comments